USAFP Research Forum - Judging Form - Clinical Investigation


Title:
Primary Author:

Rating Area Scoring (0 = Not Present; 1 = lowest to 10 = highest)
Title/References - Title reflects content with key terms for indexing; References current, thorough, appropriate
dot-clear0 dot-clear 1 dot-clear 2 dot-clear 3 dot-clear 4 dot-clear 5 dot-clear 6 dot-clear 7 dot-clear 8 dot-clear 9 dot-clear 10
Introduction/Background - Statement of purpose; Objective; Literature review; Needs assessment/Reason for intervention
dot-clear0 dot-clear 1 dot-clear 2 dot-clear 3 dot-clear 4 dot-clear 5 dot-clear 6 dot-clear 7 dot-clear 8 dot-clear 9 dot-clear 10
Methods/Intervention - Subject/Program description; Design; Tests/Instruments used - if appropriate; Procedure or Intervention
dot-clear0 dot-clear 1 dot-clear 2 dot-clear 3 dot-clear 4 dot-clear 5 dot-clear 6 dot-clear 7 dot-clear 8 dot-clear 9 dot-clear 10

Results/Outcomes - Impact of intervention (improved knowledge, skills or attitudes); Evaluation of program/intervention (feedback for improvement); Statistical analysis; Clarity of results (tables, etc)

OR

Evaluation; Appropriate to intervention based on results; Applicability/relevance; Limitations/recommendations for improvement/future; Clarity

 Confusing & dot-clear Methodologically
Inappropriate dot-clearSound


dot-clear0 dot-clear 1 dot-clear 2 dot-clear 3 dot-clear 4 dot-clear 5 dot-clear 6 dot-clear 7 dot-clear 8 dot-clear 9 dot-clear 10

Major dot-clear Clearly
Deficits dot-clear Stated
Conclusions/Discussion - Limitations; Based on data presented; Clarity; Applicability/relevance
dot-clear0 dot-clear 1 dot-clear 2 dot-clear 3 dot-clear 4 dot-clear 5 dot-clear 6 dot-clear 7 dot-clear 8 dot-clear 9 dot-clear 10
Structure - Elements present; style; grammar; clarity
dot-clear0 dot-clear 1 dot-clear 2 dot-clear 3 dot-clear 4 dot-clear 5 dot-clear 6 dot-clear 7 dot-clear 8 dot-clear 9 dot-clear 10

Comments:

Submitter Name: - Just use your Judge Designation (i.e. "Judge #23")


This page © copyright 1997-2012 by the Uniformed Services Academy of Family Physicians, a non-profit organization. Webmaster: Bob Marshall MD MPH MISM, CAPT MC USN Ret. In accordance with regulations covering all websites which are not government websites, the Department of Defense has not explicitly approved, endorsed, or authorized this web site.
 
Home |Top of Page
 


This site has been optimized for Internet browsers Netscape 4.0 or above and Internet Explorer 4.0 and above. Please go to the Netscape or Microsoft web sites to download and install browser versions above 3.0.